OK - here's a few ideas and comments on the proposals.
Fic assignments - I would prefer either that admins match request and writer, OR that requests are posted anonymously, and writers pick the one they wish to write (with a Yahoo database this can be instant. Not sure about other forums). I wouldn't want the 'draw straws' alternative where a writer might get an assignment they'd hate.
Participation - I'm not sure how to combat the 'no shows'. I think a few writers prepared to fill in the gaps would be great - and I'd be prepared to be one, though the result might not be a perfect match. I took part in a swap on another site last year, and never did get my exchange story.
Forum - no preferences.
Content - I only read/write in LOTR, so have no comment on other fandoms being added/dropped. Drabbles could be fun though.
Overall, I think the system is pretty good already, but I'm not sure how to deal with those writers who promise faithfully to deliver, but don't - apart from banning them from future participation.
no subject
Fic assignments - I would prefer either that admins match request and writer, OR that requests are posted anonymously, and writers pick the one they wish to write (with a Yahoo database this can be instant. Not sure about other forums). I wouldn't want the 'draw straws' alternative where a writer might get an assignment they'd hate.
Participation - I'm not sure how to combat the 'no shows'. I think a few writers prepared to fill in the gaps would be great - and I'd be prepared to be one, though the result might not be a perfect match. I took part in a swap on another site last year, and never did get my exchange story.
Forum - no preferences.
Content - I only read/write in LOTR, so have no comment on other fandoms being added/dropped. Drabbles could be fun though.
Overall, I think the system is pretty good already, but I'm not sure how to deal with those writers who promise faithfully to deliver, but don't - apart from banning them from future participation.
Jay